I hate to play the "village atheist," but I have to disagree with this one. The reason we don't believe in fairies, for example, is because there is no evidence for their existence. The state of the world (i.e., the evidence we have) is exactly as we expect it to be if fairies did not exist.
Compare that to something like atoms. We knew atoms exists long before atomic microscopy existed, because we could speculate on how the world would work if atoms existed, and we found through experiment it really did work that way.
If something exists in the world, we expect it to have some kind of effect on it. It may be the case that we haven't learned about the effect of something just yet (such as a god), but we don't start believing in something until we have some evidence for it. The fact that we have never found any evidence which suggests fairies exist is good evidence that they probably don't, particularly because we can come up with evidence we would expect to find if they did exist.
The saying would be better if it were: "Absence of evidence is not PROOF of absence." It's near impossible to prove something does not exist inductively. Then again, no one demands this type of proof for anything other than a god. Almost no one demands deductive proof that fairies don't exist.
I understand your point. I feel that one's belief in God cannot be studied and tested. One either believes or one does not. Love cannot be studied nor identify yet we know it exists. One can even argue that it does not exist for this same reason. Thanks for the comment, Jeff. You are such a fine person whom I am priviledged to know.
Dr. Crewson Andrew Martin, Ph.D, LCSW-R, M-C.Ht., CMFT, SPN, CWPhas over 35 years of experience treating individuals, couples, and groups. His approach is the synergistic and cybernetic relationship between mind and body.
He is a licensed Psychotherapist, Certified Master Clinical Hypnotherapist, Gestalt Therapist, Licensed Master Fitness Trainer, Certified Sports Nutritionist, and is the Clinical Director of TheSuffolk Institute for Hypnotherapy.(http://www.sihonline.net/)
Additionally, Dr. Crew is a Certified Wellness Professional and a Certified NLP Practitioner. Therapy modalities he utilizes include Mindfulness-Based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Schema Therapy, Hypnotherapy, Dialectical Behavioral Therapy, NLP (Neuro-Linguistic Programming), Meditation Therapy, Somatic Psychotherapy techniques, and Light Therapy.
He has many years of hospital and home-based medical experience and knowledge. Dr. Crew has many years of experience treating patients on Hospice programs as well their families. His clinical experience is also in psychiatric based interventions. He is a certified School and Educational Social Worker.
He is an adjunct professor atDowling College, Oakdale, NY. He maintains a private practice in Port Jefferson Village(Tonglen Psychotherapy,P.C.and Subconscious Solutions, LLC), and is the owner of Mind-Body Fitness and Strength Studio,Inc. also in Port Jefferson Village. Dr. Crew is certified to provide fitness services to children, adolescents, adults, and seniors.
Dr. Crew offers supervision for Licensed psychotherapists seeking their "R" designation. He also provides supervision and instruction for Licensed Fitness Trainers who are working towards their Master Fitness Trainer certification.
His Institute, The Suffolk Institute for Hypnotherapyalso offers courses and training in Hypnosis and Clinical Hynotherapy,Advanced Clinical Hypnotherapy (Master Clinical Hypnotherapy certification), Neuro-Linguistic Programming ,Assertiveness Training,Meditation Therapy, Schema Therapy,Somatic Psychotherapy,Parent Effectiveness Training, and Rational Emotive Therapy for practicing therapists and Allied Health professionals. Each seminar training and all courses are open to the general public and all are always welcome to attend.
Dr. Crew is a certified Clinical Hypnotherapy trainer and instructor with The American Board of Clinical Hypnotherapy and offers certification with ABCH through courses and seminars taught at The Suffolk Institute for Hypnotherapy.
Dr. Crew is a member of Weight Management and Healthy Eating Resources of Long Island, (www.eatingforwellness.com) which is an independent group of healthcare professionals dedicated to weight management, healthy living, and a healthy lifestyle.
Dr. Crew hosts a twice monthly internet television show entitled "Mind-Body Psychotherapy, Fitness, and Wellness with Dr. Crewson Andrew Martin" which can be viewed live every other Sunday from 1pm-2pm EST on Ustream.com.
2 comments:
I hate to play the "village atheist," but I have to disagree with this one. The reason we don't believe in fairies, for example, is because there is no evidence for their existence. The state of the world (i.e., the evidence we have) is exactly as we expect it to be if fairies did not exist.
Compare that to something like atoms. We knew atoms exists long before atomic microscopy existed, because we could speculate on how the world would work if atoms existed, and we found through experiment it really did work that way.
If something exists in the world, we expect it to have some kind of effect on it. It may be the case that we haven't learned about the effect of something just yet (such as a god), but we don't start believing in something until we have some evidence for it. The fact that we have never found any evidence which suggests fairies exist is good evidence that they probably don't, particularly because we can come up with evidence we would expect to find if they did exist.
The saying would be better if it were: "Absence of evidence is not PROOF of absence." It's near impossible to prove something does not exist inductively. Then again, no one demands this type of proof for anything other than a god. Almost no one demands deductive proof that fairies don't exist.
I understand your point. I feel that one's belief in God cannot be studied and tested. One either believes or one does not. Love cannot be studied nor identify yet we know it exists. One can even argue that it does not exist for this same reason.
Thanks for the comment, Jeff. You are such a fine person whom I am priviledged to know.
Post a Comment